Current:Home > reviewsColorado court upholds Google keyword search warrant which led to arrests in fatal arson -WealthFlow Academy
Colorado court upholds Google keyword search warrant which led to arrests in fatal arson
View
Date:2025-04-25 11:27:53
DENVER (AP) — Colorado’s highest court on Monday upheld the search of Google users’ keyword history to identify suspects in a 2020 fatal arson fire, an approach that critics have called a digital dragnet that threatens to undermine people’s privacy and their constitutional protections against unreasonable searches and seizures.
However the Colorado Supreme Court cautioned it was not making a “broad proclamation” on the constitutionality of such warrants and emphasized it was ruling on the facts of just this one case.
At issue before the court was a search warrant from Denver police requiring Google to provide the IP addresses of anyone who had searched over 15 days for the address of the home that was set on fire, killing five immigrants from the West African nation of Senegal.
After some back and forth over how Google would be able to provide information without violating its privacy policy, Google produced a spreadsheet of sixty-one searches made by eight accounts. Google provided the IP addresses for those accounts, but no names. Five of the IP addresses were based in Colorado and police obtained the names of those people through another search warrant. After investigating those people, police eventually identified three teens as suspects.
One of them, Gavin Seymour, asked the court to throw the evidence out because it violated the Fourth Amendment’s ban on unreasonable searches and seizures by being overbroad and not being targeted against a specific person suspected of a crime.
Search warrants to gather evidence are typically sought once police have identified a suspect and gathered some probable cause to believe they committed a crime. But in this case, the trail had run cold and police were seeking a “reverse keyword” warrant for the Google search history in a quest to identify possible suspects. Since the attack seemed targeted, investigators believed whoever set fire to the house would have searched for directions to it.
The state Supreme Court ruled that Seymour had a constitutionally protected privacy interest in his Google search history even though it was just connected with an IP address and not his name. While it also said it assumes that the warrant was “constitutionally defective” for not specifying an “individualized probable cause”, the court said it would not throw out the evidence because police were acting in good faith under what was known about the law at the time.
The court said it was not aware of any other state supreme court or federal appellate court that has dealt with this type of warrant before.
“Our finding of good faith today neither condones nor condemns all such warrants in the future. If dystopian problems emerge, as some fear, the courts stand ready to hear argument regarding how we should rein in law enforcement’s use of rapidly advancing technology. Today, we proceed incrementally based on the facts before us,” it said.
In a dissent, Justice Monica Marquez said such a wide-ranging search of a billion Google users’ search history without a particular target is exactly the kind the Fourth Amendment was designed to stop.
“At the risk of sounding alarmist, I fear that by upholding this practice, the majority’s ruling today gives constitutional cover to law enforcement seeking unprecedented access to the private lives of individuals not just in Colorado, but across the globe. And I fear that today’s decision invites courts nationwide to do the same,” she said in the dissent, which Justice Carlos Samour joined in.
In a statement, Google said it was important that the court’s ruling recognized the privacy and First Amendment interests involved in keyword searches.
“With all law enforcement demands, including reverse warrants, we have a rigorous process designed to protect the privacy of our users while supporting the important work of law enforcement,” it said.
The ruling allows the prosecution of Seymour and Kevin Bui, who were 16 at the time of the Aug. 5, 2020, fire, to move ahead in adult court on charges of first-degree murder, attempted murder, arson and burglary. Investigators allege Bui organized the attack on the home because he mistakenly believed people who had stolen his iPhone during a robbery lived there.
Telephone messages and an email sent to Seymour’s lawyers, Jenifer Stinson and Michael Juba, were not immediately returned. A lawyer for Bui, Christian Earle, could not be reached for comment.
A third teen, Dillon Siebert, who was 14 at the time and originally charged as a juvenile, pleaded guilty earlier this year to second-degree murder in adult court under a deal that prosecutors and the defense said balanced his lesser role in planning the fire, his remorse and interest in rehabilitation with the horror of the crime. He was sentenced to 10 years behind bars.
veryGood! (548)
Related
- The city of Chicago is ordered to pay nearly $80M for a police chase that killed a 10
- Inside Tatum Thompson's Precious World With Mom Khloe Kardashian, Dad Tristan Thompson and Sister True
- Takeaways from AP’s story on inefficient tech slowing efforts to get homeless people off the streets
- Chiefs' Travis Kelce in his 'sanctuary' preparing for Super Bowl three-peat quest
- Nevada attorney general revives 2020 fake electors case
- Spoilers! Let's discuss those epic 'Deadpool & Wolverine' cameos and ending
- Oldest zoo in the US finds new ways to flourish. See how it is making its mark.
- Body found in Phoenix warehouse 3 days after a storm partially collapsed the roof
- Juan Soto to be introduced by Mets at Citi Field after striking record $765 million, 15
- Life and death in the heat. What it feels like when Earth’s temperatures soar to record highs
Ranking
- Whoopi Goldberg is delightfully vile as Miss Hannigan in ‘Annie’ stage return
- Archery could be a party in Paris Olympics, and American Brady Ellison is all for it
- Secrets About the Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders Straight From the Squad
- Charles Barkley open to joining ESPN, NBC and Amazon if TNT doesn't honor deal
- Charges tied to China weigh on GM in Q4, but profit and revenue top expectations
- A Guide to Vice President Kamala Harris’ Family
- Beyoncé introduces Team USA during NBC coverage of Paris Olympics opening ceremony: Watch
- 'Olympics is going to elevate all of us:' Why women's volleyball could take off
Recommendation
The White House is cracking down on overdraft fees
Yankees land dynamic Jazz Chisholm Jr. in trade with Miami Marlins
American Carissa Moore began defense of her Olympic surfing title, wins first heat
Scuba divers rescued after 36 hours thanks to beacon spotted 15 miles off Texas coast
Where will Elmo go? HBO moves away from 'Sesame Street'
Team USA members hope 2028 shooting events will be closer to Olympic Village
How many gold medals does Simone Biles have? What to know about her records, wins, more
Paris Olympics opening ceremony: Everything you didn't see on NBC's broadcast